Most businesses are very good at adding things.
Every strategic planning session seems to produce more:
- priorities
- initiatives
- projects
- goals
- markets to pursue
- systems to implement
- products to launch
- improvements to make
Very little gets removed.
The result is predictable. The new strategy gets added on top of everything the company was already doing.
New priorities. Old priorities. New initiatives. Existing responsibilities.
Eventually, strategy starts to mean more work.
A useful strategy should do something different. It should help the business decide what deserves its limited attention, resources and energy.
And that means it should also tell you what not to do.
Strategy Requires Exclusion
Michael Porter famously argued that the essence of strategy is choosing what not to do.
That matters because virtually every strategic decision contains a trade-off.
If you decide to focus on a specific kind of customer, you are also deciding not to focus equally on every other customer.
If you decide to standardize your service, you are deciding that you will not customize everything for everyone.
If you decide that your management team needs to focus on improving the core business, you are deciding not to chase every adjacent opportunity that appears.
The positive side of strategy is usually easy to write down.
- We are going to focus on these markets.
- We are going to improve recurring revenue.
- We are going to standardize our operations.
- We are going to build a stronger management team.
The harder question is:
What are we going to stop doing, refuse to do, or deliberately ignore because of those decisions?
That is where a Do-Not-Do List becomes useful.
The Do-Not-Do List
A Do-Not-Do List is an explicit record of things your business has consciously decided not to pursue.
It could include markets, customers, projects, products, behaviours, processes, investments or management activities.
For example:
- We do not pursue projects below $100,000 unless they meet a specific strategic exception.
- We do not create a completely different workflow for every customer.
- We do not add new software unless it replaces something or solves a clearly defined problem.
- We do not open another location until the existing operation reaches defined performance targets.
- We do not require the owner to approve routine purchases below a certain amount.
- We do not launch another service until the existing service can operate without constant owner involvement.
These are not necessarily things that are bad.
Some may be excellent opportunities.
They are simply things the business has decided are not important enough right now.
That distinction matters.
A Good Idea Can Still Be the Wrong Idea
One of the hardest things for an owner to accept is that a good idea can still be a bad idea to pursue.
There are always more opportunities than there is capacity to pursue them properly.
A business has finite:
- cash
- management attention
- employee capacity
- development resources
- sales effort
- meeting time
- cognitive bandwidth
Every new initiative competes with something already underway.
That means the question cannot simply be:
Is this a good idea?
It also has to be:
Is this more important than what we have already decided to do?
Those are very different questions.
An opportunity can be profitable, interesting and completely reasonable, and still deserve a no.
Sometimes the best strategic decision is not “never.”
It is simply “not now.”
This Takes Discipline
Writing the strategy is usually the easy part.
Following it is harder.
The opportunity outside your target market will eventually appear.
A large customer will ask for an exception.
Someone will show you an interesting piece of software.
A competitor will launch something that makes you wonder whether you should launch it too.
A new market will suddenly look attractive.
The owner will have another idea.
This is where strategy is tested.
It takes discipline to look at something genuinely attractive and still say:
That isn’t what we have decided to focus on.
It takes discipline not to chase every dollar of revenue.
It takes discipline not to customize the business for every customer.
It takes discipline to leave a good idea alone while a more important idea is still being implemented.
It takes discipline to allow resources to remain concentrated instead of spreading them across ten initiatives.
Without that discipline, the strategy slowly becomes meaningless.
Every exception seems reasonable on its own.
But enough reasonable exceptions eventually produce a business that is doing everything again.
Stop Doing and Do Not Do Are Different
There is an important distinction between a Stop-Doing List and a Do-Not-Do List.
A Stop-Doing List asks:
What are we doing today that we should stop?
That is valuable.
Maybe there is a report nobody needs anymore. A meeting that serves no purpose. A service that has become unprofitable. A process that should have disappeared years ago.
The Do-Not-Do List asks a different question:
What have we decided we will not start doing?
It is preventative.
Instead of cleaning up complexity after it enters the company, you establish boundaries that help prevent unnecessary complexity from entering in the first place.
Both are useful.
One removes yesterday’s clutter.
The other protects tomorrow’s focus.
Turn Strategy Into Decision Rules
This becomes especially valuable in an owner-led business.
Consider how many questions eventually find their way back to the owner:
- Should we quote this?
- Can we customize that?
- Should we offer this service?
- Can I approve this purchase?
- Should we take this customer?
- Should we build this feature?
- Should we enter this market?
If all of those decisions require the owner, the owner is still functioning as the business’s decision engine.
A well-designed Do-Not-Do List can turn some of those decisions into company knowledge.
Instead of the owner repeatedly deciding whether to quote small projects, the company might establish:
We do not quote projects below $100,000 unless they are for an existing strategic customer.
Now there is a decision rule.
Employees can act without waiting for the owner.
This is one of the ways strategy can become part of a business operating system rather than something that exists only in a planning document.
Good strategy should help people make decisions when the owner is not standing beside them.
Then Create a Didn’t-Do List
There is another side to this idea that I think deserves more attention.
Businesses are constantly recording what they accomplished.
- We hired five people.
- We landed a $2 million customer.
- We launched a new service.
- We opened another location.
- We implemented new software.
- We entered a new market.
Visible action gets celebrated.
Restraint rarely does.
But some of the most valuable management decisions a company makes may be things that never happened.
- We didn’t hire three more people because we fixed the underlying process.
- We didn’t chase the large opportunity outside our target market.
- We didn’t introduce another piece of software.
- We didn’t build the feature one customer requested.
- We didn’t expand before the existing operation was ready.
- We didn’t start another major initiative while the current one was unfinished.
Those decisions can create enormous value, but they are almost invisible.
So alongside the Do-Not-Do List, consider keeping a Didn’t-Do List.
The Do-Not-Do List is prospective:
Here are the things we have decided not to do.
The Didn’t-Do List is retrospective:
Here are the things we had the opportunity to do, but deliberately chose not to.
One establishes the discipline.
The other shows whether you actually had it.
Review It Like Any Other Strategic Commitment
At a quarterly or annual strategy review, businesses naturally ask:
- What did we accomplish?
- What did we miss?
- What should we do next?
Add another question:
What did we say we weren’t going to do?
Then ask:
Did we actually avoid doing it?
Suppose leadership decides the company will no longer pursue projects below $100,000.
Six months later, 25% of the estimating team’s time is still being spent pricing projects below $100,000.
The strategy says one thing.
The operating behaviour says another.
That is useful information.
The Do-Not-Do List makes the contradiction visible.
The Didn’t-Do List gives you evidence when the opposite happens and the strategy is actually being followed.
Strategy Should Reduce Options
There is a natural temptation to think good strategy should create more possibilities.
Sometimes it should.
But one of the most valuable things a strategy can do is eliminate possibilities.
It narrows the field.
It tells people where not to spend their time.
It prevents every interesting opportunity from becoming an organizational priority.
It helps employees make decisions without continually escalating them.
And it protects important work from being interrupted by the next attractive idea.
That does not mean becoming rigid.
Strategies change. Markets change. Businesses learn.
The Do-Not-Do List should change too.
But those changes should be deliberate.
There is a difference between changing your strategy because you learned something important and abandoning your strategy every time something interesting appears.
The difference is discipline.
What Did Your Strategy Make You Say No To?
A useful test for any strategy is surprisingly simple:
What does this strategy cause us to say no to?
If the answer is nothing, the strategy may not have created much direction.
It may simply have added another set of priorities to everything the business was already doing.
Instead, try creating three lists:
- What are we going to do?
- What are we deliberately not going to do?
- What did we have the discipline not to do?
The first list shows your intentions.
The second establishes your boundaries.
The third tells you whether those boundaries were real.
Because strategy isn’t only demonstrated by what a business accomplishes.
Sometimes it is demonstrated just as clearly by what the business had the discipline to leave alone.
